Presentation given by Roberta Luxbacher, director Europe, ExxonMobil Gas &
Power Marketing at 12th annual FLAME Conference.
Amsterdam March 14, 2006
NOTE:This presentation includes
forward-looking statements. Actual future conditions (including economic
conditions, energy demand, and energy supply) could differ materially due to
changes in technology, the development of new supply sources, political
events, demographic changes, and other factors discussed herein (and in Item 1
of Exxon Mobil Corporation’s latest report on Form 10-K). This material is not
to be reproduced without the permission of ExxonMobil International Ltd.
Good morning I’m please to have the opportunity to address this conference and
share with you what we at ExxonMobil see as the exciting opportunities that
exist for gas in Europe.
Over the next 20 minutes or so I
will talk about how we see the global gas market developing as well as comment
on some of the risks and challenges that need to be overcome to realise the
future potential of the gas market in Europe.
I’ll start with
an overview of my talk.

Europe in a global market
First of all, I’ll share our
view on the supply and demand fundamentals for gas in Europe. Starting with
projected global economic growth, we have developed a view to 2030 on how
energy demand will grow. As you know, power generation is closely linked to
economic growth, and is the main driver for gas demand growth.
With existing gas production declining in both Europe and North America, the
growing requirement for gas imports to both continents will promote
inter-regional LNG trade, creating a dynamic global gas market.
Recognising that there will be global competition for resources and
investments. I will highlight the need for stakeholders and policy makers to
maintain a long term vision to ensure a stable and effective market framework
so that Europe can compete effectively.
Finally, looking at
how the gas market is liberalising, I will focus on the role of policy makers
to allow the market to function and to retain confidence in the power of
competitive markets, even when prices are moving rapidly.
By
the end I hope to convey to you that an open competitive market operating in a
global context when combined with an attractive investment environment and
stable predictable regulation provides the right framework to meet Europe’s
gas supply needs in the global market.

Global power and competing fuels
As I mentioned, we start with the well publicised economic growth in
developing economies, and consider what that growth means for power generation
demand.
The left panel makes this point clearly. By 2030, we
project that the total power generation outside Europe and North America to be
over 60 per cent of the world’s total.
On the right is
our projection of fuel inputs to power generation. Coal and gas today
represent about two thirds of fuel inputs and by 2030 we expect their share to
reach over 70 per cent.
As the demand for gas continues to
grow in both the developed and undeveloped economies, we are now experiencing
global competition for gas supplies.
This competition is
growing as new LNG projects come on stream linking supply sources and the
markets around the world, creating a dynamic global gas market.
If we now move on to look at Europe…

Europe supply and demand
As shown on this chart, Europe natural demand growth is expected to be about
1.2 per cent per year through 2030. We expect Europe local production to
increase over the next few years driven by new projects in Norway, but then to
peak towards the end of the decade. This combination of demand growth and
indigenous supply decline creates a need for 57 GCFD or 570 BCM of new
supplies.
Of these new supplies, we expect that up to 20 GCFD
of new LNG (shown in turquoise) is needed in addition to that already
announced. Most of this LNG is expected to come from the Middle East, North
Africa, and West Africa.
Significant new supplies of Russian
pipeline gas are also required. We expect this Russian gas to be from new
developments in West Siberia (Yamal from 2012) and the Russian Barents Sea.
In summary, Europe is expected to increase its participation in the global gas
market. Perhaps the most important aspect of the future gas market is the
significant development in competition for securing new supplies and the
resulting growth in inter-regional trade. It is in this environment that
Europe finds itself competing to attract investment for the necessary new gas
supplies.

Maintaining an effective market
In order for Europe to
compete in a global market it is vital that an attractive investment
environment is created and maintained. We are encouraged by the clear support
in this regard by the Commission and many Member State governments.
As the European gas market transforms confidence is needed in the stability
and predictability of the tax and regulatory regimes – unexpected changes will
be viewed as increased project risk.
We support the European
Commission’s efforts to balance a European open access regime with exemption
processes designed to encourage new infrastructure investment. But we believe
further steps are needed: 1) Care must be taken to avoid establishing
incentive mechanisms that promote investment by incumbent monopolies which
discriminate against new entrants 2) Regulations requiring investment
in excess re-gas terminal capacity to provide mandated third party access also
increase risks and reduce investment incentives 3) Providing effective
permitting processes to ensure timely project development will also help lower
risks and promote investment.
Laws and regulations that
inhibit the operation of competitive markets will inevitably have unintended
consequences. They will compromise Europe’s ability to attract imports from
multiple sources and thereby undermine the key liberalisation objective – the
development of a truly competitive marketplace with diversity of supply and
interdependency.
Strong, competitive markets are based on the
principles of freedom to participate in the market and freedom to negotiate
appropriate market solutions.

Europe liquidity development
Now, I’d like to look at
the status of market liberalisation in Europe..
In the centre
you see what we believe to be the key indicators for liquidity development.
The first three, Volume to Trade, Buyers and Sellers and Access to
Infrastructure, we see as fundamental. The second three we see as liquidity
accelerators.
On the right you will see that most of the
indicators are showing an increasing trend, supporting our view that the
market is developing and that the existing regulatory framework is appropriate.
The challenge on the regulatory side, as we all know, is to ensure that the
requirements of the 2nd Gas Directive are fully and effectively implemented.
Although we see the need for progress, care must be taken when introducing new
actions that are intended to accelerate liquidity to ensure that the
investment environment is not inadvertently affected.
Take
for example access to infrastructure. Development of secondary markets is
important, nevertheless, gas suppliers need assurance that their gas will have
access to the market through the life of their project. Restricting capacity
reservations or contract durations to the short term does not allow this.
Instead it potentially undermines the sanctity of existing contracts and
increases risk, stifling the large investments required to develop new
competitive gas resources.
Overall we see that the European
gas market is developing on the right track – we need to stay on course!

Multiple factors impact gas prices
This chart
highlights the multiple factors impacting gas prices. All these factors, and
this is not an exhaustive list, are legitimate influencers of price and will
impact the market to different degrees over different time periods. All of
this will lead to price movements and, of course, volatility.
Freely moving prices provide the signals necessary to balance supply and
demand and ultimately facilitate the development of a strong liquid market.
As we examine this picture more closely however, and keeping in mind the long
term nature of gas markets, there are really four key factors that I’d like to
focus on.

Fundamental price setting factors are few
Those four
factors are shown here.
I have talked about supply, and
demand, and infrastructure access.
The fourth factor we see,
shown here on the right, is Competing Energy. The natural gas market remains
subject to the effects of potential for substitution. Multiple end users and
multiple suppliers seek to optimise their own cost and risk of energy supply.
In doing this the end-users make choices, sometimes short-term choices,
sometimes longer-term choices, among the competing fuels available for their
particular application.
Gas and Oil are substitutable energy
sources in the majority of applications in the long term. Because of this
connection the price of oil is a significant factor impacting gas prices.
Often we hear that the prevalence of oil-indexation in long-term gas supply
contracts in Continental Europe is the reason for higher gas prices seen
recently. The inference is that in the absence of these contracts and the
direct contractual link to oil, gas prices would no longer be influenced by
oil prices. We believe that this hypothesis is fundamentally incorrect.

Gas prices related to alternative fuels
Gas prices
will track oil prices even in the absence of a contractual link. This can
clearly be seen when looking at the deep liquid US gas market where the prices
of competing oil products impact gas prices in both the short and longer term.
This is in a market where gas is predominantly contracted on a gas index basis.
In this chart the natural gas price at Henry Hub in the US (shown in red) is
charted over the last ten years against the prices of Distillate and Low
Sulphur Fuel Oil (both competing energy commodities) in the US Gulf Coast.
US gas prices have generally traded in a band that is competitive with Low
Sulphur Fuel Oil and capped by Distillate prices.
We expect
that as European liquidity increases, more and more buyers and sellers may opt
to contract using a gas index, but even in the absence of oil indexed gas
contracts, we believe that gas prices will continue to be influenced by oil
prices.

In conclusion
So now, let me summarise.
A well developed and competitive
market will respond to supply and demand imbalances in a timely and cost
efficient way. Healthy competition in an open marketplace will ensure Europe
benefits with globally competitive gas prices.
In addition,
such a marketplace will respond to Europe’s growing import dependency by
developing cost effective and timely supply projects which increase diversity
and security of supply. (In Europe we are fortunate that 70 per cent of global
gas reserves lie within economic transportation distance of the market. More
supplies can be attracted if we can maintain a framework that encourages
investments in infrastructure, such as LNG terminals, that enables timely
permitting and approvals, and allows for long-term capacity reservations.)
We believe that governments and regulators must ensure the three market
framework fundamentals exist: 1) a beneficial investment environment
2) light-handed stable regulation, and, 3) an open and competitive
marketplace.
The energy market is capital intensive and
complex. The pace of change in the market may not always meet expectations.
Short-term measures to manipulate one portion of it can have unintended
consequences elsewhere. Over-regulation can be counterproductive, and hence it
is better to rely on market forces.
Finally, I hope I have
demonstrated that a competitive market when combined with an attractive
investment environment and stable predictable regulation provides the right
framework to meet Europe’s gas supply needs in the global market. We are on
the track, we need to stay the course!
Thank you for
listening to our views.
|